Tuesday, October 18, 2011

Lambs to the Slaughter

 Poetry is more than worthless words on paper, stitched together to make a little rhyme. It is more than silly anecdotes meant to take up your time. Lyrics are of the same nature and are not just a pretty tune. They are meant to inform the reader of a situation or event that has a profound effect on the writer. Even when poems and lyrics to songs are written at different times about different things they can still tie into each other.  Stephen Crane’s poem “War Is Kind” and the song “Hunting for Witches” by Bloc Party both show how blind obedience can be foolish and detrimental to society.
http://famouspoetsandpoems.com/poets/stephen_crane/photo
            In the poem “War is Kind,” Crane uses irony to show how wars are far from kind and instead shows the less appealing side of war. He uses a father who will never see his child, a son who will never come home, and a lover who died so young to show how their lives were worth more than a quick death on a battle field. They have a blind obedience to the war they are in and Crane makes it almost comical how willing they are to go into the battle field. Whereas in the song “Hunting for Witches” by Bloc Party they are also showing how blind obedience can be detrimental to society and how misinformation can warp what you should and should not do. Instead of using irony they use metaphor to tell you how the society is being misinformed and how the media is keeping everyone trapped in their own fear. 
           Crane shows how the society itself is pushing these men into the war by exalting killing and showing how glorious the war is. He uses the irony in the words he chooses as well, in lines 20 and 21 he states,
            Point for them the virtue of slaughter,
            Make plain for them the excellence of killing
It is ironic because there is no virtue or excellence in taking a life of another person because they are someones father, someones son, and someones lover. In this verse Bloc Party shows you this media influence,
          
                1990's, optimistic as a teen
But now its terror, airplanes crash into towers
The Daily mail say's "the enemy is among us!"
"Taking our women and taking our jobs"
All reasonable thought is being drowned out
By the non-stop baying, baying for blood.(10-15)


When I first heard this song I remembered walking in the hallway at school on September 11th and the principle coming over the loud speakers to tell us all that planes were falling out of the sky, she didn't say there had been an accident, she didn't say anything about the towers. Her words were "planes are falling out of the sky" she gave more information after that but at the age of 11 those were the only words I heard. I walked home that day and when I got there my mom was watching the news as it kept showing the planes hitting the towers over and over. A few months later my cousin, Ray enlisted into the United States Army and was in Iraq in no time. December 7th, 2003 just 7 days before they caught Saddam Hussein he was coming back from a mission in Mosul, Iraq when an improvised explosive device exploded under his Humvee, killing him instantly, or at least they tell us instantly. He was 20 when he died, fighting a war that the media pushed to be just, a war they claimed was worth the lives of our family. Even in 1899 Crane could see what war does to society and to the people who live in it and Bloc Party could see, at their young age, that this war was nothing but a witch hunt. 
Crane emphasizes what he thought war did by using repetition with the phrase “Do not weep./ War is kind” through the whole poem. This emphasizes a need to cry, a need to feel pain because what is happening is not kind in any way. His poem is almost asking how can they not weep at the loss of life, like lambs to the slaughter they obey their orders blindly for an unexplained glory. In his poem he states:


                Little souls who thirst for fight,
These men were born to drill and die.
The unexplained glory flies above them,
Great is the battle god, great, and his kingdom
A field where a thousand corpses lie.(7-11)
The unexplained glory is their blind obedience, not knowing what they are fighting for yet they still fight because they believe they are fighting for something a something that society has imposed upon them. Block party shows how the media influences the information that society receives, silencing reasonable thought by pushing for action to be done in response to the twin towers falling.  The song’s chorus is a more comical aspect of the song, using a little history to show people how foolish what they are doing actually is. The chorus they say “I go hunting for witches/ Heads are going to roll/ So I go hunting" and is repeated throughout the song to add emphasis, similar to the way "Do not weep./ War is kind." is repeated in Crane's poem. The enemies that the media shows them are the witches, but just like witches the enemies are just a ploy to keep society trapped in their own fear, blindly following the path that has been chosen for them.
          
http://www.blocparty.com/pictures.php
            Each is writing to a specific audience in the poem “War is Kind” it is speaking to the families of the soldiers or future soldiers, most likely people who do not know much about war and the little they do know is coming from the radio and news papers. The radios and newspapers though aren’t allowed to tell them everything that is going on and is most likely dolling up the information to make it seem more glorious. Crane uses words that most likely are quite shocking to many readers like the word slaughter or corpse, that aren’t typically in a normal conversation. In “Hunting for Witches” Bloc Party is speaking more to the American population that is going overboard trying to hunt the terrorist witches, when in reality they are hunting innocent people. Although "War Is Kind" was written before "Hunting for Witches" it shows what the future will hold when the witch hunting goes overboard and a full blown war is undertaken. Both speak to people who are in the thick of the trouble, the people who are doing the hunting and the people waiting at home for the hunters to come back, leaving an emotional impact on each one.
            Both “War is Kind” and “Hunting for Witches”, written over a century apart warn of the dangers of blind obedience, though each writer does it in their own way. Where Crane uses irony to show this blind obedience, Bloc Party uses metaphors, both exposing the dangers that comes being blind to war. They show that there is more than just following and that it’s important to get all the information.

No comments:

Post a Comment